Monday, November 30, 2009

The Lost Garden

After you have read "The Lost Garden", what do you think the main conflict in the story was? What type (internal or external) was this? What effect did this conflict have on the main character in the story? Please answer in at least three to four complete sentences.

24 comments:

Kaitlyn Tulenko said...

The main conflict in this story, in my opinion, is that the child and grandmother did not understand the same language. It was an internal conflict because it was a language issue. The child was not willing to learn her grandmother's language in school and never overcame the language barrier between the generations.

Morganne Degroot said...

I think the conflict in this story was that the chinese-american boy did not know alot about his heritige.He did not do very good in his chinese class and did not speak any chinese.

I think it was an external confilict because he grew up in america and he was not born in china so he did not know much about his heritige.

It effected him because he could not speak to his grandma because she did not know any english.

Erik Lepisto said...

I think a main conflict in this story is that the kid gets put in a class with a really mean teacher that beats kids.

I think this is external because the teacher is beating kids.

This conflict has a effect on the main character because she is mean and yells at kids and could make him scared.

Elizabeth Tulenko said...

I think the internal reason is that the grandmother speeks another launge. The grandson can't speek chiense. The external reason is the boy likes mashg potates.

Derek Moore said...

I think the internal reason about how the grandson is trying to speak chinese.And it is hard for him when there is a bunch of chinese around.

I think the conflict is when the grandmother and grandson have a tuff time.when they meet there saying a different languge. So that means there is somthing different about both of them.

Ben Carew said...

I think the major conflict in this story is that the kid's Grandma speaks Chinese and the kid doesn't. He wants to learn Chinese so he can communicate with his Grandma better but he doesn't want to.
This is internal conflict because he was having like an arguement in his head with himself.
This conflict had an effect on the main character because he couldn't decide if he wanted to do the work to learn Chinese or just blow it off and not be able to understand his Grandma fully.

John Tulenko said...

I think the conflict is two different languages in one family. Internal conflict is that the child does not want to learn the language at school in the dummy class. He struggles to talk to his grandmother and never gets to know her.

Ryan McMorrow said...

I think a main conflict in this story is that the boy can't communicate with his grandmother because they speak different languages.

I think this is internal conflict because not being able to communicate with someone is more in the head than it is physical.

The effect is that the boy and grandmother can't talk about things like the grandmother's life and when she was a kid.

Brianna Alberts said...

The boy did not knew a-lot about where his annsisters came from.
External because he really did not knew a whole lot about his faimlys past.
he did not know chinnies and she did not knew about english.

Matt Guilette said...

The internal conflict is that he wants to learn Chinese but does not want to be your average Chinesian. This is internal because it is not like he is fighting "the war on how to learn Chinese". It all takes place in his head. This had him spend a lot more time on projects.

Matt Guilette said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Matt Guilette said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Hannah Braun said...

The main conflict in The Lost Garden is, when the boy speaks english but his grandmother speaks spanish.

This was a internal conflict the boy had.

This conflict had a effect on the boy because, he wanted to learn spanish so he could talk with his grandma but he wasn't good at it at all.

Christian Schmidt said...

I think the main conflict is internal, because the boy is in a conflict of trying to pass the course but while doing that, not learning Chinese, this would be hard to do because if you would get a random question concerning Chinese in her class, which could easily happen, she'd need to be prepared or the teacher may get suspicious...

Quest Simmerman said...

I think the main conflict is the kid and the teacher because the teacher beats the kids.
i think it is external because the teacher beats kids.
it had effect on him by the teacher making him scared.

Zach Gruetzmacher said...

I think the main conflit was that the boys Grandma speaks chinese and he didnt know how to speak chinese or learned chinese.

This is internal conflit because it is a issue for him to learn chinese or not.

The effect is that if the boy didnt learn how to speak chinese he wouldnt understand his Grandma.

Adee Van Zeeland said...

I think that the conflict is an internal one because the boy has a problem with tring to pass the course and while he was doing that he was not exactly learning chinese. You should prolly be prepared.

Brianna Zoran said...

I think the confilct is internal becasue the boy speaks english and his grandmother speaks chinese and it was hard for him to learn chinese.
The effect was the boy wanted to speak chinese so he would be able to understand his granmother and if he didn't, he couldn't communicate with her

Benjamin A Newman said...

I think the main conflict was he didnt speak chinese very good but his grand ma could and it was hard for him.
The effect was he had to learn chinese to speak with his grandma and if he didnt they wouldnt be able to talk at all.

Ethan Berkley said...

I think the main conflict was because they couldnt speak of each others nationality.

internal.

the effect was that the guy had to learn chinese so they could understand each other.

Willy Brietzke said...

i think the main conflict is external because,everything around the boy is chinese.He is american-chinese and he dosnt care to learn chinese.It is very hard for him to communicate with his grandmother because he only understands a little chinese,and his grandmother can only speak a little english.

Zak Eckrose said...

I think the main conflict of the story internal, because the kid is trying to learn chinese so he and his grandma can talk to each other. Because of this the boy and his grandma can't talk about what they've done during the day. He tried going to a american-chinese school, he didn't end up learning anything.

Jacob Bolwerk said...

In my opionion, the main conflict was having 2 cultures in one family, chinese and american. I think this conflict was an internal confict. The effect that the conflict had on the main character, was that he only wanted to be american, and I think he felt bad about it later, because his grandmother was chinese, and I think he realized he was growing away from her.

Claire Dagesse said...

I think the main conflict in the story is that the boy and his grandmother speak two different languages. The boy speaks english and the grandmother speaks chinese.

I think it was internal conflict.

It effected the boy because he would have to learn chinese to speak with his grandmother or they wouldn't be able to talk to eachother.